Nobody can say how many university application essays are now written by AI. Everyone who reads them for a living agrees the answer is a lot.
Kate Gilbertson, who graduated from UC Berkeley in 2025 and now edits applications full time, described how she notices. She has been getting drafts that lack the usual roughness of teenage writing. "Those little moments of flaw tell me that this is still a 17-year-old's writing, right?"
The part that closes the loop
Colleges generally disapprove of applicants using AI. A number of them are also using AI to evaluate the essays those applicants send in.
UNC-Chapel Hill went furthest, automatically scoring application essays on writing quality — and then reversed the decision. The reason, reported by the student newspaper, is the interesting bit: a university spokesperson said "the widespread use of AI-assisted writing tools was the factor diminishing the usefulness of AI essay ratings".
That is a closed circle, and it broke from the inside. If machine-written text is uniformly competent, a machine grading it for competence stops separating anyone from anyone.

Some colleges are removing the essay instead
More universities are dropping supplemental essays for this application cycle. Tulane no longer requires its "Why Tulane?" question.
Spokesperson Michael Strecker told CNN the essay had not mattered much in recent selection anyway — but confirmed that concerns about AI did play a role in dropping it.
Where the essay survives, guidance is being rewritten. CalTech draws the line at voice: replacing your own tone with generated content is unethical, while using a model to generate questions that start your brainstorming is acceptable. The University of Pennsylvania has warned against AI in letters of recommendation written by counsellors and teachers.
'Students are moving faster than admissions offices'
That is Ashley Pallie, CalTech's dean of undergraduate admissions, and it is the honest summary of the whole situation.
Her office cut thousands of applicants down to fewer than 450 admitted students last year. She argues the work is more art than science and that no model replaces professional readers soon: "You actually can't develop the perfect formula that's going to choose the right students for you. You do need humans who are reading the humans who submitted their application."
CalTech is not AI-free, though. It uses a model that reads applicants' scientific research and generates questions for faculty to look at afterwards — assistance rather than judgement.
Pallie's preferred future is less technological than you would expect. "In our ideal world, everyone would do an interview of some sort." The style of interview? "Human."
Where AI genuinely helps
The least controversial use is the earliest step: deciding where to apply at all.
A private admissions consultant costs thousands of dollars. Michael Koppenheffer of the education firm EAB put the case directly: "For a lot of students, AI is the college counsellor they can't afford."
EAB found AI now has an outsized influence on where students apply compared with university websites and search. In its survey, 82% of students who used AI tools in their college search named ChatGPT.
One parent, Christine Wilson in Virginia, hired a counsellor for her son and then rebuilt the shortlist herself with AI, generating a spreadsheet of the 22 universities he applied to with cost of attendance modelled against income and likely aid.
What the essay was for
Sophie Sajnani, who runs a small consulting firm, made the point that gets lost: "The reason we still have the admissions essay is to show a moment of growth. It's less so about the writing and more so to show situations and how a student has grown from it."
If that is true, the threat is not bad prose. It is that a model cannot supply the moment of growth, and an essay with no such moment reads fine and says nothing.
For students in Bangladesh applying abroad, the practical reading is narrow and useful. Use a model to find universities, model costs and check your evidence. Do not let it supply the experience — that is the only part of the form that was ever yours.




