World Technology

The upgrade caused the outage: what grounded a million US passengers

America's air traffic system did not simply break down from old age. It broke while being modernised — which is a far more uncomfortable finding, and a familiar one.

The upgrade caused the outage: what grounded a million US passengers

On Friday afternoon the Federal Aviation Administration ordered a rare nationwide ground stop. By the time it was lifted just after 8pm Eastern, 9,200 flights had been cancelled, according to FlightAware. Another 6,200 went on Saturday because crews and aircraft were in the wrong places. More than a million passengers were affected.

The cause is the uncomfortable part

The system did not simply give out from old age. The problem started when a contractor was replacing copper wire with fibre optics — that is, during an upgrade intended to fix exactly this kind of fragility.

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin put it bluntly: "That new equipment, new technology just was overwhelming the older system. The patchwork doesn't work."

The component that failed was the part that monitors and communicates with aircraft at cruising altitude. Once it could not be relied on, planes already in the air could not safely be kept there in the usual numbers, and new departures had to stop.

New fibre, old system, one afternoon
9,200 flights on Friday, 6,200 more on Saturday, over a million passengers. Graphic: Tech BD.

What the system is actually made of

US air traffic control handles more than 45,000 flights a day, and genuine failures are rare. It does this on equipment that would be unfamiliar to most people working in technology today.

Controllers still hand each other paper strips carrying flight names. Floppy discs are in use. Copper wire carries communications for close to a third of the system.

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy described the stack without softening it: "We use 1980s technology, 1990s software, to use 1970s radar that we don't make parts for anymore."

Travel analyst Henry Harteveldt of Atmosphere Research Group offered the plain comparison. Keep a car for thirty years and spare parts get harder to find every year. The same is true of any technology serving any industry.

Why this is hard, in Duffy's own words

"I don't want to lie to anybody," Duffy said on Friday night. "What we're doing is hard, and it hasn't happened in the past because it is hard. But I'll tell you, by doing nothing, you inject way more risk into the system."

That is the real trap. The system cannot be switched off while it is replaced, so the new has to be grafted onto the old — and Friday is what happens when the graft does not take.

Readers who followed our coverage of the Microsoft outage last week will recognise the shape of this. There too, the failure came from a change made to a running system under load, not from the system quietly rotting.

It is not only the regulator

Airlines run old software too. In July 2024 a CrowdStrike update broke Windows machines worldwide, and Delta struggled longest because its crew-tracking software would not come back.

Over the 2022 year-end holidays Southwest cancelled 16,700 flights at a cost of at least $1bn, largely because its crew scheduling system required phone calls rather than online check-ins. It has since spent at least $1.3bn on upgrades.

Harteveldt explained the incentive clearly: airlines would rather spend on Wi-Fi, new aircraft and lounges, which passengers can see. They are risk-averse about back-office technology, and even in good years the margins do not leave much room for it.

The number that decides what happens next

Congress approved $12.5bn for air traffic control upgrades last year. Before Friday, Duffy had asked for another $30bn. By Friday night the figure had become $50bn.

Whether the weekend's disruption wins that money is a political question, not a technical one. "Is this exact thing going to happen again? I don't know," Duffy said. "I think there's no better time than the present to actually give us the money and let us finish."

Source: CNN

Written by

Tech BD

Tech BD is an independent technology publication based in Dhaka, published in English and Bangla. Articles appear under the masthead rather than under individual bylines; corrections and source questions reach the editor at info@tech-bd.com.