Technology Popular

A 170-year-old maths problem may have fallen to an AI. The proof runs to 250,000 pages

The claim is extraordinary and the caveats are just as large. Nobody has checked it yet, and the one person who can explain it is human.

A 170-year-old maths problem may have fallen to an AI. The proof runs to 250,000 pages

An Anthropic employee and mathematician says he used the company's AI chatbot to prove the Riemann hypothesis — a problem that has stood for nearly 170 years.

Levent Alpöge said on Friday, a day after Anthropic's US stock market debut, that over roughly six weeks he used the Claude chatbot to build a detailed proof. If it holds up, it would be among the most significant proofs in history.

He described it as "one dawn across science of something far greater".

What the problem is

The hypothesis is named for the mathematician Bernhard Riemann. It proposes that prime numbers follow a determined order along the number line.

That sounds abstract, and the reason it matters is not. Prime numbers are the bedrock of higher mathematics, so a genuine breakthrough about them ripples outward into a great deal of other work. It is widely considered the single most famous problem in maths, largely because of how hard it is.

372 more problems claimed
OpenAI, a month after Navier-Stokes. None confirmed yet. Photo: unknown photographer, Wikimedia Commons.

The caveats are as large as the claim

This is where a reader should slow down, because the headline and the status of the work are not the same thing.

The proof was produced using a non-public version of Claude. The complete text, written in Lean — a computer language used to confirm mathematical proofs — runs to over 250,000 pages.

Terence Tao, one of the most prominent mathematicians alive, said on Friday that verification is still some way off.

"I imagine the digestion process will take some time, though in this case at least we have a human author to communicate with to assist with this task," Tao said.

That last clause is the most useful sentence in the whole story. The problem with the recent wave of AI-produced proofs has not only been whether they are correct — it is that there was often nobody to ask. Here there is a named mathematician who can explain his own reasoning.

The timing, and what he said about it

Alpöge said he messaged Anthropic chief executive Dario Amodei on Sunday asking how he should announce the discovery. He was blunt about how the announcement would look, coming a day after the company listed its shares.

"The precise timing is horrible," he said. "If I could have, I'd have finished this all much earlier."

"I am clearly unilaterally responsible for feeling I just could not live if I waited even longer. There is an obvious cynical view, to do with the timing, but it is false."

Mathematicians are not uniformly pleased

The claim lands in a year of them. In September, OpenAI said employees using a non-public version of its tools solved part of the Navier-Stokes equations, which describe how fluids move, in just 88 hours — using more than 10,000 AI agents as a training exercise. That proof has still not been confirmed as accurate.

A month later OpenAI released what it said were solutions or major progress on 372 more open problems. Reviewing those claims will take months at least.

A group of mathematics scholars wrote that AI companies boasting of major solutions to demonstrate how sophisticated their commercial products had become was "detrimental to the science of mathematics".

"We are witnessing a general threat to intellectual work, with misalignment between the outcome of the use of AI and its initial purpose," they wrote.

Disclosure: Anthropic makes the AI model used to draft posts on this site. This report is based on BBC copy and carries the criticism of the practice alongside the claim.

Source: BBC

Written by

Tech BD

Tech BD is an independent technology publication based in Dhaka, published in English and Bangla. Articles appear under the masthead rather than under individual bylines; corrections and source questions reach the editor at info@tech-bd.com.