World Health

Britain is going to measure what its under-16 social media ban actually does

Australia banned first and is still arguing about results. Britain is building the measurement before the law lands, which is the unusual part.

Britain is going to measure what its under-16 social media ban actually does

More than 300,000 young people in Britain will work with researchers to establish what the country's forthcoming social media ban for under-16s actually does to their mental health.

The ban begins in spring 2027 and follows the model already introduced in Australia, stopping children from accessing platforms such as Instagram, TikTok and Snapchat.

What is being measured

Ten separate projects have been commissioned across England, Wales and Scotland, funded by the health charity the Wellcome Trust.

Researchers will use wearable technology, smartphones, digital diaries and surveys to track how young people respond, physically and mentally.

Two of the questions are more interesting than "did wellbeing improve".

The first is what children do instead — whether they spend less time on their phones at all, and what replaces the scrolling if they do. A ban that moves attention from one app to another app is a different outcome from a ban that moves it off the screen.

The second is whether they find ways around the restrictions. That is being studied deliberately rather than treated as an embarrassment, which matters, because a rule that is widely circumvented produces measurements about circumvention rather than about social media.

What replaces it, and who gets round it
Both are being measured deliberately, starting before the 2027 ban. Graphic: Tech BD.

Who is being studied

Participants are being recruited to reflect a genuinely wide range of young people: different genders and sexual orientations, young people who are neurodivergent, and those with existing mental health conditions such as anxiety and depression.

That last group is the one that makes the study worth running. The plausible case for a ban and the plausible case against it both concentrate on the same children — those already struggling, for whom online spaces may be either a source of harm or a source of support. A study that sampled only typical teenagers would miss the entire argument.

The research groups are at Cardiff University, the University of Oxford, the University of Birmingham, King's College London, the University of Edinburgh, the University of Manchester, the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine and University College London.

What the funder is careful not to claim

Dr Camilla Iannone, research lead at Wellcome, called it a once-in-a-generation opportunity to study at scale how social media and its restrictions affect youth mental health.

Her framing was notably cautious. "We really don't think that this is a simple binary question of whether social media is good or bad, or whether restrictions work or don't work," she said.

Instead, the teams will study "whether changing young people's digital environment leads to meaningful changes in their mental health and wellbeing".

Some early results are expected before the ban takes effect, which is the whole point of starting now: without a baseline there is nothing to compare the after to.

Australia is the reason this is being done properly

Australia introduced its ban last December, and it has yet to produce clear results.

Supporters say it is protecting young people from harmful content. Critics say it has been too harsh. Both sides are largely arguing from the same absence of evidence.

There have also been reports of Australian teenagers finding ways around the ban, and the UK government has promised tougher blocks.

Meanwhile the forum Reddit and a digital rights group are in a High Court battle in Australia, arguing the law is unconstitutional.

Why this is worth watching from here

Several countries are now considering age limits on social media, and the evidence base they will cite is largely being created by these two experiments. Australia produced the policy; Britain is producing the measurement.

For anywhere weighing a similar rule, the British data will be the more useful of the two — not because the policy is better, but because somebody wrote down what things looked like beforehand.

Source: BBC

Written by

Tech BD

Tech BD is an independent technology publication based in Dhaka, published in English and Bangla. Articles appear under the masthead rather than under individual bylines; corrections and source questions reach the editor at info@tech-bd.com.