Popular Technology

GTA VI scored 99 on Metacritic, tying the highest-rated game ever made

Thirteen years, several delays and $1.5bn of pre-orders before a single copy shipped. The reviews answered the only question left.

GTA VI scored 99 on Metacritic, tying the highest-rated game ever made

The review embargo on Grand Theft Auto VI lifted on Wednesday morning, hours before release, and more than 150 critics published at once.

The aggregate score on Metacritic is 99. That makes it the joint highest-rated game ever made, level with 1998's The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time — the only other title to reach 99.

Why the number is a genuine surprise

The game had been in development for 13 years, the longest gap between releases in the franchise's history, with multiple delays along the way. Expectations had been built up for over a decade, which is usually the setup for a disappointment.

The Verge's Andrew Webster put it directly: "Grand Theft Auto VI does something impossible — it lives up to the hype."

Rockstar has been here before. GTA IV (2008) and GTA V (2013) also sit near the top of Metacritic's all-time list, so the studio has a record of clearing bars it set itself.

99, tied with Ocarina of Time
150+ reviews, 13 years of development, $1.5bn in pre-orders. Graphic: Tech BD.

What the critics actually praised

Not the driving or the shooting. The thing reviewers kept returning to was the relationship at the centre of the story — Jason and Lucia, a Bonnie-and-Clyde pair trying to leave a life of crime.

"The series matures beyond its memorable car crashes and stickups with a game about love, relationships and nurturing your partner," wrote Yussef Cole in the New York Times, noting that the characters' scripted choices reflect how the player has behaved toward them in the quiet moments between missions.

The second thread was density of detail. Ars Technica's Kyle Orland described being "slack-jawed" at things like "a laptop screen partially reflected in a character's glasses" and "the finger smudges visible on your cell phone in bright sunshine".

IGN's Luke Reilly called it "a world that feels more lived-in and real than anything I've ever played — unprecedented, unbelievable, unmissable".

The Guardian's Keza MacDonald offered the most useful framing for anyone deciding whether to buy: reviewing it "feels a bit like trying to review, say, Paris: it contains so many potential experiences that it's hard to know where to start".

And Forbes' Paul Tassi recorded the strangest compliment of the batch. "The first time I ran a red light in Grand Theft Auto 6, I cringed. It was just too real."

The money was settled before anyone played it

Pre-orders are estimated to have passed $1.5bn, according to market intelligence firm Sensor Tower. Nine days before launch the game had already cleared $1bn in pre-order revenue — almost twice what Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II, the best-selling US game of 2022, had made at the same point.

That is the part worth understanding about modern games: the commercial outcome was decided before the reviews existed. The reviews determine how long it lasts, not whether it succeeded.

The real business is what comes after

GTA V was the bestselling game of 2013 and has gone on earning for over a decade, largely through GTA Online, the multiplayer expansion that arrived weeks after launch. GTA Online alone has made over $5bn in ten years, through new content and in-game purchases rather than copies sold.

The franchise now sits about 40 million copies short of the all-time top spot, behind Tetris, Pokémon and Call of Duty. On these numbers that gap does not look likely to last.

Source: CNN

Written by

Tech BD

Tech BD is an independent technology publication based in Dhaka, published in English and Bangla. Articles appear under the masthead rather than under individual bylines; corrections and source questions reach the editor at info@tech-bd.com.