Technology World

Waymo has pulled its driverless taxis off every US freeway, not just California's

A regulator banned it in one state. Waymo went further and stopped everywhere, which tells you something about what it does not yet know.

Waymo has pulled its driverless taxis off every US freeway, not just California's

Waymo has temporarily suspended its driverless vehicles from operating on all US freeways.

The decision follows a California ban on Waymo's driverless taxis using state freeways, imposed after a series of traffic incidents.

What the regulator actually said

California's Department of Motor Vehicles cited an "imminent hazard to public safety".

The specific trigger was an incident this month in which several driverless Waymo vehicles entered an active construction zone on US Route 101, south of San Francisco.

The DMV said the risk came from "recurring incursions by its vehicles into active construction zones where construction workers, vehicles and equipment are present". The word doing the work there is recurring — this was a pattern, not a single event.

The ban took effect on 11 November and stays until Waymo "demonstrates to the department that it has taken effective corrective actions to address the deficiencies that precipitated the restrictions".

No injuries or collisions were reported in the Route 101 incident, Waymo said.

"Recurring incursions"
Construction zones with workers present, on US Route 101. Banned 11 November. Graphic: Tech BD.

Why the voluntary part is the interesting part

California banned Waymo from California freeways. Waymo stopped freeway operations everywhere.

"In alignment with our safety-first principles, we have also temporarily restricted freeway operations across our other operating markets to evaluate our performance," a spokesperson said.

That is a reasonable thing to say, and it is also a disclosure. A company confident the problem was specific to one stretch of Californian road would have paused that road. Pausing every freeway in the country implies Waymo does not yet know what the behaviour depends on — and would rather not find out while carrying passengers at freeway speed.

There is another incident in the background. Earlier this month, footage widely shared on social media appeared to show a Waymo car trying to overtake patrol vehicles that were deliberately slowing traffic on a San Francisco highway.

Both episodes have the same shape: the car met a situation where the correct behaviour is set by a human authority on the road rather than by the road markings, and it did the wrong thing.

What is still running

Waymo operates driverless taxis in 15 US cities, but offered freeway rides in only a handful of them — including San Francisco, Los Angeles and Miami.

The taxis continue to operate normally on ordinary city streets. For most riders in most cities, nothing changes.

Waymo said it is working with state officials "diligently and responsibly to resume freeway operations".

The safety record, and why it does not settle this

Data on Waymo's own website indicates its cars are involved in 95% fewer crashes resulting in serious injury than human drivers.

That figure is probably the single strongest argument for the technology, and it does not resolve the present problem. A regulator is not weighing average harm across millions of miles; it is weighing a specific repeated failure around road workers. A vehicle can be much safer than a human on aggregate and still be unacceptable in one identifiable situation.

This is not the first recall-shaped event

In May, Waymo recalled thousands of self-driving cars in the US over a software issue that could let vehicles drive into flooded roads.

In the same month, several Waymo cars were seen circling a cul-de-sac in Atlanta in the early hours of the morning.

Taken together, the pattern is consistent: the hard cases are not ordinary traffic, which Waymo handles well, but the edges — water across a road, a closed lane with people working in it, a police vehicle deliberately breaking the normal rules of the road.

Those are exactly the situations where a human driver reads intent rather than geometry, and they are the remaining distance between a very good driving system and a finished one.

Source: BBC

Written by

Tech BD

Tech BD is an independent technology publication based in Dhaka, published in English and Bangla. Articles appear under the masthead rather than under individual bylines; corrections and source questions reach the editor at info@tech-bd.com.